Controversy Brews Over Qurbani Ban at Kolkata Mission: Diplomatic Gesture or Political Misstep?
News Desk | PoriPurno.com
Published: May 20, 2025
A controversial directive issued by Shabab Bin Ahmed, the newly appointed Deputy High Commissioner of Bangladesh in Kolkata, has sparked intense debate both within diplomatic circles and the Bangladesh mission itself. The instruction to halt the traditional Qurbani (ritual animal sacrifice) during Eid-ul-Azha at the mission—reportedly made even before his official assumption of duty—has triggered widespread reactions.
Background of the Qurbani Ban
Although Shabab Bin Ahmed is yet to formally take charge—his official appointment begins on June 2—he has already directed mission staff to refrain from organizing any Qurbani activities during the upcoming Eid.
In defense of his decision, he stated, “Earning the confidence of our host country is extremely important. Most of the security personnel stationed at our mission worship cows. Out of respect for their beliefs, we should make thoughtful decisions.”
He also cited practical and legal concerns: “No other Bangladeshi mission outside Kolkata observes Qurbani. The practice causes sanitation issues in the vicinity, and there is also a Kolkata High Court ruling prohibiting the slaughter of animals in public spaces.”
Internal Division and Diplomatic Backlash
The unilateral move has stirred dissatisfaction among mission officials. Several staff members have voiced their disagreement, stating that such a sensitive decision should not be made without prior consultation with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
A senior diplomat expressed frustration: “The Deputy High Commissioner has not yet formally assumed office, yet he is making major decisions on religious and cultural matters. This is not only surprising but diplomatically and politically risky.”
Increase Your Business with Expert Digital Solutions!
Get Unlimited Facebook Ad Credit, Guaranteed SEO Rankings, & Professional Web Development – all under one roof at MahbubOsmane.com!
14+ Years of Experience – Guaranteed SEO Rankings
800+ Satisfied Clients – Unlimited Facebook Ad Credit
Proven Results, Maximum ROI – Professional Web Development
Contact us ( +8801716988953 WhatsApp ) today and take your business to the next level! Visit: MahbubOsmane.com
A Tradition Spanning Three Decades
For over 30 years, Qurbani has been an established tradition at the Bangladesh Deputy High Commission in Kolkata. Typically, 5–7 cows and goats are sacrificed, and the meat is distributed to local orphanages and the surrounding Muslim community. This longstanding practice has reportedly been viewed positively by the West Bengal government as an example of religious harmony.
Another seasoned diplomat remarked, “Under Mamata Banerjee’s government, West Bengal has set a strong example of religious tolerance. The Qurbani at our mission reflects that spirit. Halting it could provoke a political backlash and offer ammunition to parties like the BJP and RSS.”
Praise from Indian Media and Geopolitical Implications
Shabab Bin Ahmed’s appointment has already garnered attention from Indian media, particularly outlets sympathetic to the Modi government. India Today recently published a favorable report, suggesting that he could play a pivotal role in strengthening bilateral ties.
However, analysts warn that such overly cautious diplomatic moves could destabilize the delicate balance in Bangladesh-India relations and may trigger resentment among Bangladeshi Muslims.
Final Thoughts
While the decision to ban Qurbani at the Kolkata mission may have been framed as an effort to earn the host country’s trust, its religious, political, and social implications are far-reaching. Whether the directive proves to be prudent or problematic remains to be seen—but for now, it has already stirred a storm within the mission and the wider diplomatic arena.
Do you still have questions? Or would you like us to give you a call?
Call us at wa.me/+966549485900 or wa.me/+8801716988953 to get a free consultancy from our expert or you can directly email us at hi@mahbubosmane.com We would be happy to answer you.
